American Edge Project Pushes Against AI Regulation with Alarmist Ads
- Campaign Expenditure: American Edge Project spent between $150,000 and $190,000 on Facebook ads opposing AI regulation.
- Main Arguments: Ads claim AI regulation will harm small businesses and give China a competitive advantage.
- Contradictory Public Opinion: Despite the campaign, a poll shows most Americans prefer a cautious approach to AI development.
Meta-funded American Edge Project, often described as “Facebook’s anti-regulatory attack dog,” has launched a significant campaign against AI regulation. The group spent between $150,000 and $190,000 from February to June on Facebook ads designed to incite public opposition to AI regulation efforts, according to data analyzed by Transformer.
Campaign Expenditure and Messaging
The American Edge Project’s ad campaign, consisting of over 150 ads, employed alarmist language to mobilize viewers. The ads predominantly conveyed two main arguments: AI regulation would damage small businesses and allow China to surpass the US in AI technology. These ads have reached between 6 and 7.5 million viewers, urging them to contact their representatives and oppose “anti-innovation legislation.”
The campaign painted AI regulation as beneficial to China, calling it “pro-China legislation.” A template letter provided by the campaign warns lawmakers that “China is already accelerating its lead over the United States in artificial intelligence (AI) patent filings” and urges them to consider the potential negative consequences of AI regulation.
Contradictory Public Opinion
Despite these efforts, public sentiment appears to favor a more cautious approach to AI. A recent poll indicated that both Republican and Democrat voters believe it is more important to take a careful, controlled approach to AI development than to rush to be the first country to develop powerful AI.
Broader Advocacy and Financial Backing
The American Edge Project has been a vocal opponent of tech regulation, heavily funded by Meta. It received $38 million from Meta in the 2019-2020 fiscal years and an additional $47.5 million in the 2021-2022 fiscal year, though the sources of these donations remain undisclosed due to the group’s legal structure.
Meta, which is developing the Llama series of open-source large language models, has consistently opposed significant AI regulation efforts. Nick Clegg, Meta’s president of government affairs, and Yann LeCun, Meta’s chief AI scientist, have both expressed concerns that regulation could hinder innovation.
Strategic Outreach
In addition to Facebook ads, American Edge is pushing its anti-regulation message through other channels. Board members have published op-eds in Newsweek, and CEO Doug Kelly has warned about the dangers of “anti-innovation regulations” in various public statements. The group is also sponsoring tech policy newsletters in outlets like Axios and Politico.
When asked about the campaign, Doug Kelly stated, “China has a $1.4 trillion dollar plan to supplant the United States as the world’s technology leader. The threats to America’s technological edge, especially from China, could directly jeopardize our national security and economic well-being.”
The American Edge Project’s aggressive campaign against AI regulation highlights the ongoing tension between tech industry interests and public policy. While the group warns of potential competitive disadvantages and national security risks, public opinion suggests a preference for a more measured approach to AI development. As the debate continues, the role of influential tech companies and their funded advocacy groups remains under scrutiny.